Case Docket · Criminal Law
The Single-Life Rule: The Supreme Court analyses the scope of Section 31 CrPC in Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra
On this page

Can a person serve two life sentences sequentially, or does a single natural life mark the absolute boundary of custodial punishment? This fundamental dilemma of sentencing jurisprudence lies at the heart of the case against Raju Shantaram Koli.
On April 29, 2010, Koli arrived at the minor victim’s house, where he raped and strangulated the minor, shortly after which he fled the house, but later he was traced and apprehended by the police. He was tried before the Additional Sessions Judge, Thane,1 and was subsequently convicted and sentenced, vide judgement dated September 27, 2013, under Section 3022 and 3763 (r/w Section 342)4 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) (corresponding to Sections 1035 and 646 (r/w Section 127(2)7 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023). On both counts, he was handed a separate sentence of life imprisonment, along with a fine of ₹5,000. Notably, the Trial Court directed these sentences to run consecutively, rather than concurrently. This sentencing was originally challenged by Koli in the Hon’ble Bombay High Court,8 challenging both the conviction and the sentence. The High Court, through its judgement dated 10th June, 2016, dismissed the appeal, and upheld Koli’s conviction on both counts. On the question of the direction of consecutive sentences, the High Court stated that it “would not like to interfere”. Koli then filed another petition before the Bombay High Court,9 where he prayed that both the life sentences awarded to him be directed to run concurrently, rather than consecutively. A division bench of the Bombay High Court dismissed the petition, holding that a writ cannot review or alter a final judgement passed by a coordinate bench. However, the Court left it open to the accused to approach the Hon’ble Supreme Court to challenge the judgement dated 10/06/2016, passed by the High Court. Koli took this liberty, and the matter ultimately reached the Hon’ble Supreme Court through two connected appeals: one arising out of the dismissal of the writ petition10 and the other directly challenging the High Court’s 2016 appellate judgment on consecutive life sentences.11
The primary issue to be decided before the Supreme Court was “whether the Trial Court as well as the High Court were justified in imposing consecutive life sentences in a single trial for offences under Section 302 and Section 376 read with 342 of the IPC”.
Basing its judgment on Muthuramalingam and Others v. State Represented by Inspector of Police,12 the Supreme Court reaffirmed that life sentences awarded for multiple offences in a single trial cannot run consecutively. Analysing Section 31 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 197313 (CrPC) (corresponding to Section 25 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023),14 the Court noted that while Section 31(1)15 allows imprisonment terms for multiple convictions in a single trial to run consecutively, Section 31(2)16 sets strict limits to such directions. Specifically, when consecutive fixed-term sentences are ordered, the aggregate imprisonment cannot exceed 14 years, nor can it exceed twice the maximum punishment the court is competent to inflict for a single offence
The Court next turned to the question of the duration of a sentence for life imprisonment. Reaffirming Gopal Vinayak Godse v. State of Maharashtra,17 along with multiple other cases, it was reiterated that a life imprisonment sentence means imprisonment for the remainder of a convict’s natural life, unless such sentence is remitted or commuted. It should be noted that Section 433A18 of the CrPC (corresponding to Section 475, BNSS)19 mandates a minimum 14-year term to be served by the convict in cases of commuted death sentences. Consequently, the Court held that Section 31(1) CrPC permits consecutive sentencing strictly for fixed-term imprisonment, observing that directing life sentences to run consecutively is “anomalous and irrational”, as it disregards the fundamental reality that a convict has only one natural life to serve.
After this, the Court examined the question of serving consecutive life sentences. Referring to the case of Ranjit Singh v. UT of Chandigarh,20 where consecutive life sentences were awarded across separate trials were challenged under Section 42721 CrPC (corresponding to Section 467, BNSS),22 the Court noted that the Parliament was cognizant of the irrationality of a convict serving life imprisonment twice over, which led to the insertion Section 427(2).23 To prevent such anomalies and irrationality, the Court extended the same logic to Section 31, and held that consecutive sentencing under Section 31(1) applies strictly to fixed terms, whereas life sentences “can and must run concurrently”. Overruling Duryodhan Rout v. State of Orissa,24 the Court clarified that this prohibition of consecutive life sentences stems not from the 14-year ceiling in Section 31(2), but from reading Section 31(1) alongside Section 427(2), grounded in the principle that life imprisonment spans a convict’s full natural life, making sequential execution a juristic impossibility.
The Court then stated that they were “inclined to hold that if more than one life sentences are awarded to the prisoner, the same would get superimposed over each other”. The key legal consequence of this superimposition is that executive remission or commutation granted for one life sentence operates independently, such that it does not automatically trigger the remission or commutation of the remaining life sentences being served by the convict. This doctrine of superimposition rests on a twofold rationale. First, because a human being has but one life to live, ordering life sentences to run consecutively creates an obvious physical and juristic anomaly and impossibility. Second, a convict sentenced for multiple grave offenses should not receive an unwarranted windfall, where executive remission or commutation granted for one crime automatically wipes out the punishment for another. By directing multiple life terms to run concurrently through superimposition rather than an aggregation, the law preserves the independent legal existence of each sentence while allowing them to execute in parallel.
Critiquing Kamalanatha v. Tamil Nadu,25 which held that “imprisonment” under Section 31 CrPC includes life terms, the Court rejected any interpretation permitting consecutive life sentences, reiterating that a convict has only one life to serve. The Court concluded that multiple life terms in a single trial cannot run consecutively; instead, they are superimposed over each other. Consequently, executive remission or commutation granted for one offence does not ipso facto remit or reduce the sentence awarded for another.
Concluding, the Supreme Court upheld the decisions of the Trial Court and the Bombay High Court, regarding the life sentences imposed under Sections 302 and 376 r/w 342 of the IPC. However, it partially set aside the lower courts’ orders, to the extent that they directed the sentences to run consecutively. It ordered that both life terms be superimposed to run concurrently, ensuring that executive remission or commutation granted for one sentence does not automatically extend to or remit the other.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court resolved the sentencing dilemma by applying the doctrine of superimposition from the Muthuramalingam case, establishing that while multiple life sentences cannot run consecutively end-to-end under Section 31 CrPC, neither do they merge into a single indivisible punishment. Instead, multiple life terms run in parallel, while retaining their distinct legal identities, carrying vital executive ramifications – an executive grant of remission or commutation for one offense does not ipso facto extend to the superimposed life term for another. By setting aside the Bombay High Court’s directive for consecutive life terms and ordering their superimposition, the Supreme Court harmonised biological reality with retributive justice, preventing the legal impossibility of consecutive life terms while ensuring that offenders of multiple grave crimes do not receive an unearned windfall through blanket executive remission.
Citations
- Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, Session Case No. 282 of 2010 (Additional Session Judge, Thane). ↩︎
- Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act 45 of 1860), § 302. ↩︎
- Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act 45 of 1860), § 376. ↩︎
- Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act 45 of 1860), § 342. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act 45 of 2023) § 103. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act 45 of 2023) § 64. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act 45 of 2023) § 127(2). ↩︎
- Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, Crl. A. No. 975 of 2014 (Bombay HC). ↩︎
- Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, Crl. WP No. 842 of 2024 (Bombay HC). ↩︎
- Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, Crl. A. No. 5072 of 2026 (SC). ↩︎
- Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, Crl. A. No. 5073 of 2026 (SC). ↩︎
- Muthuramalingam and Others v. State Represented by Inspector of Police, (2016) 8 SCC 313. ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 31. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act 46 of 2023), § 25. ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 31(1). ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 31(2). ↩︎
- Gopal Vinayak Godse v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1961 SC 600. ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 433A. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act 46 of 2023), § 475. ↩︎
- Ranjit Singh v. UT of Chandigarh, (1991) 4 SCC 304. ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 427. ↩︎
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act 46 of 2023), § 467. ↩︎
- Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act 2 of 1974), § 427(2). ↩︎
- Duryodhan Rout v. State of Orissa, (2015) 2 SCC 783. ↩︎
- Kamalanatha and Others v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2005 SC 2132. ↩︎
Expositor(s): (Intern) Priyangshu Bishayee
Topics
This article is for information only and is not legal advice. Read the disclaimer